Why startup staff might lose cash with the federal government’s inventory transfer


Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman whereas presenting her second Union Finances final month proposed to defer the train tax on ESOPs (Worker’s Inventory Possession Plan) in “eligible startups” by 5 years, or to the time of sale of shares, or when the worker leaves the startup – whichever is earlier.

Earlier than the Finances announcement, startup staff had been required to pay tax each time they exercised their possibility to purchase the corporate’s shares at a predetermined value and in addition pay taxes on capital positive aspects each time they bought these shares.


“At the moment, ESOPs are taxable as perquisites on the time of train, and this results in money circulation issues for workers who proceed to carry them for the long run,” the Finance Minister had stated throughout her Finances speech earlier than asserting the train tax deferment. 

You will need to notice although that the twin taxation regime, which specialists imagine is “draconian”, nonetheless stays. 

Throughout her speech, Ms Sitharaman additionally occurred to focus on the truth that startups, throughout their early life, have a tendency to make use of ESOP to draw and retain expertise. Nevertheless, many within the startup ecosystem imagine that the deferment of train tax will do little or no on the bottom.

“It’s not turn out to be a lot worse, however it has not turn out to be higher both,” says Ganesh Nayak, Director of Bengaluru-based startup funding platform LetsVenture. One of many Bengaluru agency’s endeavours is to assist firms create a balanced method to ESOP liquidity, and drive significant discussions between founders, HR heads, and board members, working carefully with the startup ecosystem.

Why solely ‘eligible startups’?

A significant disappointment within the Finances announcement lies in the truth that the brand new rule solely applies to “eligible startups”, that are primarily nearly 200 early-stage startups who’ve utilized and obtained 80 IAC tax exemption (with standards like incorporation after April 1, 2016); not the 28,000-odd startups recognised by the Division for Promotion of Business and Inside Commerce (DPIIT), Ganesh factors out.

Saurabh Garg, Co-founder of Bengaluru-based real-estate startup NoBroker, says the brand new adjustments are “clearly very restrictive”. 

“We arrange NoBroker in 2014 and we don't fall within the ambit itself. In any case, 5 years is just too small a interval. It (train tax) ought to have been deferred by no less than eight years if not by 10, to make any actual distinction.”

The business has been lobbying for the train tax to be abolished altogether and been making a case for tax to be levied solely on the time of precise sale of the shares by staff, with none caveats on the period of employment or timing of train. 

NoBroker’s Saurabh echoes the business’s views concerning the superb state of affairs being the scrapping of the train tax altogether. “There ought to solely be a capital achieve tax when the startup worker is promoting the share, identical to it occurs in inventory markets.”

Many, like Deepak Agarwal, Co-founder of Delhi-based startup Auric, imagine that ESOPs are simply “paper foreign money”, until the second liquidation occurs.

“Taxing folks earlier than they’ve made cash is a worrying factor,” says Deepak.

Tax ought to solely be levied on the capital positive aspects, when the worker sells their shares, he stresses, reverberating the emotions of Saurabh and the remainder of the business.

There may be virtually no worth for the ESOP right here as a result of startups which were integrated after April 1, 2016, haven’t even hit $100 million in valuation. And their ESOP isn’t going to be liquidated any time quickly,” LetsVenture’s Ganesh says. 

The authorities ought to broaden the scope of ESOP tax reduction to all non-public and unlisted firms, and never limit it to solely startups integrated submit April 2016 and authorised by the Inter-Ministerial Board, he provides.

Is there a vibrant aspect?

Though the precise tax legal responsibility for startup staff who train their inventory possibility stays the identical, they’ll now turn out to be a shareholder with out paying the earnings tax (sometimes above 30 % typically) on the time of exercising their ESOP. Moreover, if staff maintain the shares for greater than two years they’ll save 10 % on Capital Features Tax as properly, Ganesh notes.

It could seem to be there’s a vibrant aspect to the finance minister's Finances announcement, in any case. However in actuality, the draw back or the danger staff tackle with this modification might very properly override the positives. 

“The train tax is calculated based mostly on the truthful market worth (FMV) of shares on the time of train. If for any cause, the valuation of the startup declines, the worker is at a loss, because the tax has been calculated based mostly on a better valuation. Additionally, the worker can’t depart the startup, with out triggering the cost of the tax, severely proscribing the worker’s profession decisions,” Ganesh says.

The considerations should not ill-founded, on condition that down-rounds do occur. 

Final 12 months, ecommerce startup Shopclues’ valuation got here down drastically to $80 million from a $1.1 billion valuation in 2016, after Singapore’s Qoo10 Pte Ltd acquired it in an all-stock deal in 2019.

Cab-hailing firm Ola’s valuation had come right down to $three billion from $four.5 billion in 2017, when it raised a contemporary spherical of funding. Nevertheless, it did shoot again up later to greater than $5 billion final 12 months after the $74 million funding spherical from present investor Steadview Capital.  

Coming again to Nirmala Sitharaman’s announcement, one can take coronary heart in the truth that ESOPs at startups have caught the federal government’s consideration. Whereas the most recent transfer might yield treasured little, it’s maybe a sign in the appropriate path. 

(Edited by Teja Lele Desai)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here